My Office's Listings

Some or all of the listings below are provided by the Scheetz office.
$559,900 (USD)
Active

Columbus Area Residential Home

Active

1004 16th Street Columbus, IN 47201

3 Bed
3 Baths
4088 sqft
MLS# 22133474
Some homes have character. Others have a story worth telling! One remarkable property, so many ways to make it yours! Built in 1890 by Henry Horn, this striking Victorian offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Columbus history. Imagine a grand single-family residence, a live/work lifestyle, professional offices, or an income-producing investment! Currently configured with professional offices on the main level and living quarters upstairs, this historic beauty showcases craftsmanship rarely found today. Two beautifully carved staircases, original woodwork, classic pocket doors, and inviting covered porches add timeless charm. Multiple entrances and eight off-street parking spaces provide exceptional flexibility. Extensive improvements blend historic character with modern functionality, including foundation repairs, updated heating systems on both levels, upstairs hardwood flooring, and significant exterior renovations in 2025 featuring porch roofing, siding and trim repairs, and complete exterior painting. Additional updates include ductwork, attic insulation, irrigation, and fencing. Located near Donner Park and zoned CN (Commercial Neighborhood), this unique property is ready for its next chapter. Live upstairs and work below, explore rental opportunities, or restore this Victorian treasure to a magnificent single-family home! Potential uses subject to applicable zoning approvals.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Jena Glick, Century 21 Scheetz
$530,000 (USD)
Active

Harrison Area Residential Home

Active

1141 Pintail Court Columbus, IN 47201

2 Bed
2 Baths
2080 sqft
MLS# 22070039
Located in the desirable Pintail enclave of Tipton Lakes in Columbus, Indiana, this fully renovated, move-in ready brick ranch combines refined finishes, convenient main-level living, and low-maintenance features. With easy access to downtown Columbus and I-65, it offers a comfortable home base for everyday living and travel. The bright, flowing layout features abundant natural light, a skylight in the entry, and engineered hardwood flooring throughout the main living spaces. In the great room, custom built-in bookshelves add architectural character and practical storage, crafted by the same custom cabinet maker featured in the kitchen for a cohesive design. The beautifully appointed kitchen showcases quartz surfaces, custom cabinetry, a generous central island, and abundant storage. New window shades throughout most of the home provide convenient privacy and light control. The primary suite features a spacious, zero-entry curbless shower and generous closet space. A second bedroom, full bath, and versatile flex space with excellent home office potential provide additional options for guests, hobbies, or working from home. Glass doors open to a covered patio and professionally landscaped setting, creating an inviting space to enjoy the outdoors. The HOA cluster fee includes lawn mowing and fertilization, reducing routine exterior upkeep and adding convenience for those who travel or simply prefer to spend less time on lawn care. Enjoy the Tipton Lakes community's walking trails and water features, with convenient access to downtown Columbus, Harrison Lake Country Club, and I-65 for travel to Indianapolis or Louisville. This thoughtfully updated home brings together quality finishes, easy single-level living, and a location that makes coming and going convenient.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Stacy DeVreese, Century 21 Scheetz
$523,260 (USD)
Active

Hamblen Area Residential Home

Active

1 Sweetwater Drive Nineveh, IN 46164

4 Bed
3 Baths
2424 sqft
MLS# 22121371
Build a new home in Brown County on two adjoining wooded lots in the Sweetwater Lake community. This proposed Davis Homes build features the Sutcliffe B Modern Farmhouse, offering approximately 2,424 square feet of finished living space with four bedrooms, two-and-a-half baths, a two-car garage, covered front porch, gathering room, kitchen with dining nook, main-level primary suite, additional bedrooms, and loft space. The proposed design can accommodate a crawl, partial basement, or full basement foundation, subject to site conditions and builder approval. The Modern Farmhouse elevation combines horizontal and board-and-batten siding with substantial exterior posts, a covered front porch, and classic farmhouse-inspired architectural details that complement the wooded setting. The two adjoining lots provide an opportunity to build a new construction home surrounded by the natural setting of Brown County. Property owners in the Sweetwater Lake community have private access to Sweetwater Lake, including the beach, boating, fishing, swimming, and other recreational amenities available through the Cordry Sweetwater Lakes Conservancy District. Located within convenient reach of Nashville, Columbus, and Indianapolis, this property offers an opportunity to build a new Davis Homes residence in the Brown County area while enjoying access to Sweetwater Lake amenities. This is a proposed build. Final home design, dimensions, specifications, features, selections, pricing, site costs, foundation type, and construction details are subject to builder approval, site conditions, buyer selections, and final plans. The proposed home and elevation are shown for illustration purposes. The property does not have direct shoreline access for a private dock.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Stacy DeVreese, Century 21 Scheetz
$505,000 (USD)
Active

Nineveh Area Residential Home

Active

8616 S Riser Drive Nineveh, IN 46164

3 Bed
2 Baths
1434 sqft
MLS# 22126352
Lake life begins here! Set along approximately 100 feet of shoreline on East Lake in Princes Lakes, this beautifully designed waterfront home offers the rare combination of newer construction, generous outdoor living, and easy access to the water with minimal stairs. Built in 2016, the home features an open-concept layout filled with natural light, engineered hardwood flooring, and wonderful lake views. The kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, a walk-in pantry, and an easy connection to the dining and living areas, where a gas fireplace creates a cozy gathering place. Step outside to an impressive 34x19 waterfront deck made for summer cookouts, sunset conversations, and days spent overlooking the lake. The primary suite feels like a private retreat with direct access to its own 8x16 covered deck, a walk-in closet, dual vanities, and a tiled shower. An attached 2-car heated garage includes a spacious 10x24 storage area above, while the 32x50 space beneath the home and an additional mini barn provide exceptional storage for lake gear, outdoor furniture, and more. With your own dock, boat slip, mature trees, and multiple places to relax by the water, this is more than a home. It is the lake lifestyle you have been waiting for. Furnishings may also be available for purchase, making it even easier to begin enjoying lake life right away.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Jena Glick, Century 21 Scheetz
$465,500 (USD)
Active

Columbus Area Residential Home

Active

2656 Daffodil Court W Columbus, IN 47201

4 Bed
3 Baths
3575 sqft
MLS# 22130225
Welcome to 2656 Daffodil Ct W, a custom-built ranch home in Wildflower Commons with approximately 3,575 square feet of finished living space and a thoughtful, highly functional floor plan. The main level features 10-foot ceilings in the entry and great room, creating an open and welcoming feel. The great room is finished with crown molding, while the primary bedroom features a tray ceiling, walk-in closet and ensuite bath with double sinks, a soaking tub and separate shower. The kitchen offers custom cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and abundant storage, with a breakfast area and formal dining room. The split-bedroom floor plan includes three bedrooms on the main level, a dedicated office and main-level laundry. The finished basement provides additional living space with a fourth bedroom, full bath and large family room, along with substantial storage. The flexible layout provides defined spaces while maintaining a connected feel throughout the home. Outside, the covered front porch leads to a rear deck and lovely paver patio, creating an inviting space for outdoor living. The fully fenced backyard sits on a cul-de-sac lot with sidewalks. The established Wildflower Commons location offers convenient access to shopping, downtown Columbus and I-65. An attached two-car garage and full basement provide additional everyday function and storage. Custom-built with quality details, generous storage and versatile living space, 2656 Daffodil Ct W offers a well-designed ranch floor plan in a convenient Columbus location.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Stacy DeVreese, Century 21 Scheetz
$375,000 (USD)
Active

Columbus Area Residential Home

Active

1647 Washington Street Columbus, IN 47201

5 Bed
2 Baths
2966 sqft
MLS# 22109300
If you've been waiting for a house with a little more personality, allow us to introduce you. Built in 1922 and completely reimagined by Homes by Keeno, this five-bedroom home is proof that historic charm and bold modern design make a pretty spectacular pair. The charcoal brick exterior and arched entry are just the beginning. Step into the original brick foyer and discover bright, connected living spaces, a showstopping wood-burning fireplace, and a charming library that's practically begging for a good book and a great chair. The kitchen brings the drama in all the right ways: warm wood cabinetry, black countertops, statement hex tile, and pantry storage that keeps the everyday clutter out of sight. But the real magic? Room to live however you want. Two main-level bedrooms, two more in the finished basement, and an expansive upstairs primary retreat mean there's space to spread out, host guests, work from home, or finally claim a room for your hobbies. Movie nights downstairs? Absolutely. A quiet upstairs escape? Yours. Every corner pairs thoughtful design with the character you simply can't manufacture in a brand-new build. And with an extensive renovation behind the beautiful finishes, this isn't a home asking you to spend your weekends on a project list. Forget cookie-cutter. Forget ordinary. This isn't just a renovation. It's a reinvention. And it's completely Keeno unique.
Listing Courtesy of MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID / Listed By: Laura McGurk, Century 21 Scheetz